Evaluation of Rural Roads Maintenance and Management Performance
Based on BSC-FAHP and Grey Clustering Evaluation Model

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1674-0696.2022.04.08

Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University(Natural Science) ›› 2022, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (04): 46-53.DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1674-0696.2022.04.08

• Transportation+Big Data & Artificial Intelligence • Previous Articles Next Articles

Evaluation of Rural Roads Maintenance and Management Performance Based on BSC-FAHP and Grey Clustering Evaluation Model

LI Hailian1,2, LIN Wangdong1, LIN Mengkai1,2, MA Ziyuan1

(1. School of Civil Engineering, Lanzhou Jiaotong University, Lanzhou 730070, Gansu, China； 2. Key Laboratory of Road ＆ Bridge and Underground Engineering of Gansu Province, Lanzhou Jiaotong University, Lanzhou 730070, Gansu, China)

Received:2021-01-04 Revised:2021-05-10 Published:2022-04-13

基于BSC-FAHP和灰色聚类评价模型的农村公路养护管理绩效评价

李海莲1,2，蔺望东1，林梦凯1,2，马子媛1

(1. 兰州交通大学土木工程学院，甘肃兰州 730070； 2. 兰州交通大学甘肃省道路桥梁与地下工程重点实验室，甘肃兰州 730070)

作者简介:李海莲（1983—），女，河北秦皇岛人，副教授，博士，主要从事土木工程建造与管理方面的研究。E-mail：17834040@qq.com 通信作者：蔺望东（1997—），男，甘肃天水人，硕士研究生，主要从事农村公路养护管理方面的研究。E-mail：2580515441@qq.com
基金资助:
国家自然科学基金项目（51868042）；甘肃省自然科学基金项目（20JR10RA229）；甘肃省高等学校创新基金项目（2021A-048）；甘肃省青年科学基金项目（17JR5RA087）；甘肃省高等学校创新能力提升项目（2019B-055）；兰州交通大学青年科学基金项目（2017016）；兰州交通大学“百名青年优秀人才培养计划”基金项目（2018103）

Abstract

Abstract: Scientifically evaluating rural road maintenance performance has become an important problem to be solved in rural road maintenance and management. The performance evaluation index system and the hierarchical structure of rural road maintenance management was established by using balanced card theory. A fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP) was proposed to improve the weight calculation method of the performance evaluation index of the rural road maintenance management. Through the sensitivity analysis, the proposed method was proved to be robust. A grey cluster model of rural road maintenance performance evaluation was established. The rural highway maintenance management performance evaluation level was determined according to maximum membership principle. The proposed model was applied to comprehensively evaluate the maintenance management performance of a rural road maintenance station in Liangzhou District, and the feasibility of the proposed method in the performance evaluation of nural road maintenance and management was verified. The results show that the proposed evaluation method can evaluate the performance of rural road maintenance and management objectively and effectively, which has good applicability and reliability, and can be well applied to the performance evaluation of rural road maintenance and management.

Key words: traffic and transportation engineering; rural roads; performance evaluation; balanced scorecard; analytic hierarchy process; triangular fuzzy number; grey clustering method

摘要： 科学地评价农村公路养护管理工作绩效，已成为农村公路养护管理工作中亟待解决的重要问题。笔者采用平衡计分卡理论建立农村公路养护管理绩效评价指标体系以及层次结构；提出一种模糊层次分析法（FAHP）改进农村公路养护管理绩效评价指标权重计算方法，并通过敏感性分析研究指出该方法具有鲁棒性；建立农村公路养护管理绩效灰色聚类评价模型，依据最大隶属度原则确定农村公路养护管理绩效评价等级。应用该评价模型对凉州区一农村公路管养站养护管理绩效进行综合评价，验证该方法在农村公路养护管理绩效评价工作中实施的可行性。结果表明：该评价方法能对农村公路养护管理绩效做出客观有效的评价，具有良好的适用性和可靠性，能够很好的应用于农村公路养护管理绩效评价工作。

关键词: 交通运输工程; 农村公路；绩效评价；平衡计分卡；层次分析法；三角模糊数；灰色聚类法

CLC Number:

U418.2

LI Hailian1,2, LIN Wangdong1, LIN Mengkai1,2, MA Ziyuan1. Evaluation of Rural Roads Maintenance and Management Performance Based on BSC-FAHP and Grey Clustering Evaluation Model[J]. Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University(Natural Science), 2022, 41(04): 46-53.

李海莲1,2，蔺望东1，林梦凯1,2，马子媛1. 基于BSC-FAHP和灰色聚类评价模型的农村公路养护管理绩效评价[J]. 重庆交通大学学报（自然科学版）, 2022, 41(04): 46-53.

References

［1］傅小华，黎志成，徐国光. 公路养护现代化评价指标体系研究［J］.公路，2004(5):161-165.
FU Xiaohua, LI Zhicheng，XU Guoguang. A study on evaluation index system of highway maintenance modernization［J］.Highway, 2004(5):161-165.
［2］王成. 北京市公路养护管理绩效评价体系构建的探讨［J］.公路,2007 (12):123-128.
WANG Cheng. Discussion on the construction of performance evaluation system for highway maintenance management in Beijing［J］.Highway,2007(12):123-128.
［3］梁国华,杨琦,马荣国. 农村公路绩效评价指标体系的构建方法［J］.中国公路学报,2007，20(6):111-116.
LIANG Guohua, YANG Qi, MA Rongguo. Approach to construction of index system of performance evaluation about rural highway［J］. China Journal of Highway and
Transport,2007,20(6):111-116.
［4］马书红,王圆圆. 公路养护项目实施效果评价体系研究［J］.中外公路，2011,31(3):283-287.
MA Shuhong, WANG Yuanyuan. Research on evaluation system of the implementation effect of highway maintenance project［J］. Journal of China & Foreign Highway
，2011,31(3):283-287.
［5］马书红. 农村公路规划与执行绩效评价体系研究［J］.重庆交通大学学报(自然科学版),2008，27(1):113-117.
MA Shuhong. Research on performance evaluation system of rural roads planning and practice［J］. Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University(Natural Science),2008，27
(1):113-117.
［6］朱洁,李莉. 公路综合养护专项绩效评价方法研究［J］.公路交通技术,2019,35(5):59-66.
ZHU Jie,LI Li. Research on special performance evaluation method of highway comprehensive maintenance［J］. Technology of Highway and Transport，2019,35(5):59-66.
［7］周文燕. 农村公路养护管理绩效评价研究［D］.天津：天津大学，2015.
ZHU Wenyan.Research on Performance Evaluation of Maintenance Management for Rural Roads ［D］. Tianjin: Tianjin University ,2015
［8］赵显. 新疆地区公路养护管理绩效评价研究［D］.乌鲁木齐：新疆大学，2018.
ZHAO Xian.Study on Performance Evaluation of Highway Maintenance in Xinjiang Area［D］.Urumqi: Xinjiang University ,2018.
［9］朱洁, 陈长, 孙立军. 公路养护绩效评价指标体系的构建方法［J］.同济大学学报（自然科学版），2012,40(6):871-875.
ZHU Jie, CHEN Chang, SUN Lijun. Construction of index system of performance evaluation about highway maintenance［J］. Journal of Tongji University (Natural Science
)，2012,40(6):871-875.
［10］ LIU Y, ECKERT C M, EARL C. A review of fuzzy AHP methods for decision-making with subjective judgements［J］. Expert Systems with Applications, 2020,
161:113738.
［11］ CSUTORA R, BUCKLEY J J. Fuzzy hierarchical analysis: the Lam-bda-Max method［J］. Fuzzy Sets & Systems, 2001, 120(2):181-195.
［12］ NEPAL B, YADAV O P, MURAT A. A fuzzy-AHP approach to priori-tization of CS attributes in target planning for automotive product development［J］. Expert
Systems with Applications, 2010,37(10):6775-6786.
［13］ KWONG C K, BAI H. A fuzzy AHP approach to the determination of importance weights of customer requirements in quality function deployment［J］. Journal of
Intelligent Manufacturing, 2002, 13(5):367-377.
［14］宋国森,陆键,邵军.基于灰色理论的高等级公路养护质量综合评价模型研究［J］.交通信息与安全,2011,29(2):32-35.
SONG Guosen, LU Jian, SHAO Jun. Comprehensive evaluation model for highway maintenance quality based on gray theory［J］. Journal of Transport Information and
Safety,2011,29(2):32-35.

[1]	LI Ming ，LI Tei-qiang. Framework design of pavement management dystem nased on GIS [J]. Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University(Natural Science), 2005, 24(5): 34-38.
[2]	LI Ming ， CHEN Qian-ying ， PENG Ke—gang ， MA Zai-liang. Development summarization of pavement management system [J]. Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University(Natural Science), 2005, 24(3): 69-73.
[3]	REN Chao. Expressway’s multiple-project management information systems [J]. Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong University(Natural Science), 2005, 24(3): 74-76.

Evaluation of Rural Roads Maintenance and Management Performance Based on BSC-FAHP and Grey Clustering Evaluation Model

基于BSC-FAHP和灰色聚类评价模型的农村公路养护管理绩效评价

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 3

Recommended Articles

Metrics